Suspensions in the Chicago Public Schools

The following is an excerpt from an article about school suspensions in Chicago:

Nearly 45,000 of Chicago Public School’s more than 410,000 students were suspended at least once last year, according to district data.

Though that number is down from the 2007-2008 school year, it is still high, activists said at a South Side community meeting at the end of January. More than that, one Chicago pastor said, it is an issue the next Chicago mayor will have to reckon with.

Suspensions can be a pipeline – leading from dropped-out straight to prison, said the Rev. Robert Biekman, of Southlawn United Methodist Church in Chicago’s Avalon Park neighborhood.

“There are some children that probably need to be suspended,” said Biekman, de facto spokesman for High HOPES – Healing Over the Punishment of Expulsions and Suspensions. “It is a tool, but not the only tool.”

The campaign is part of a larger network of advocacy groups within the Community Renewal Society, a faith-based social justice organization with headquarters in the Loop.

At the meeting, the group called on Chicago mayoral candidates to support its campaign to reduce suspensions and expulsions 40 percent by trying alternatives.

Here is what the mayoral candidates who addressed student discipline said they would do:

Gery Chico: “Will evaluate and assess student behavior to identify problems early before they endanger teachers and other students.”

Rahm Emanuel: “Will replace the assistant principal role with a director of family and community engagement. This person would manage all extended time programming and would be charged with parent organizing, training and enlisting assets of parents in the school.”

Carol Moseley Braun: “Will follow the model created by the Baltimore Public Schools for reducing dropouts and absenteeism by creating a graduated system of consequences and interventions from student misconduct and only suspending students for dangerous behavior.”

Studies have shown that students who are suspended even once are more likely to drop out of school.

With no high school diploma, college isn’t an option and job prospects are bleak. CPS has historically had a high dropout rate.

Click here to read the entire article.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School Pushout, School to Prison Pipeline | Comments Off on Suspensions in the Chicago Public Schools

Schools Really Need to Stop Suspending Youth Because of Hair Issues…

Here’s another case of sheer stupidity. For her 12th birthday, Stephanie Plato was allowed to get a new hair color. She ended up getting an in-school suspension as another “gift.”

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies | Comments Off on Schools Really Need to Stop Suspending Youth Because of Hair Issues…

Suspended from Kindergarten…

By Megan Kenny

From the Audacious Ideas Blog:

The Maryland State Department of Education recently released its data on suspensions, expulsions, and health-related exclusions for the 2009-2010 school year. As I was preparing an OSI-Baltimore factsheet using the numbers, an alarming data point arose: 75 pre-K students in Maryland received an out-of-school suspension or were expelled during the school year. The punished incidents include: disrespect (3), classroom disruption (12), refusal to obey school policies (7), and inciting/participating in disturbance (4).1

Of course, the details of each incident remain unknown but it seems as if some of these children are being punished for simply being four years old. Medline Plus, a service of the National Library of Medicine/National Institutes of Health, states that the typical four-year-old:2

  • Lacks moral concepts of right and wrong
  • Is rebellious if expectations are excessive
  • Will ask the most questions of any age
  • May use words that aren’t fully understood
  • May begin using vulgar terms, depending on their exposure
  • Tries to be very independent
  • May show increased aggressive behavior

Without knowing the facts of each case, one might say that some of the disruptive behaviors leading to the out-of-school suspension can be directly connected to age-appropriate actions by the four-year-old child. As a former special education teacher of four-year-olds, I can tell you that not a day went by when a student did not aggress. We did not chalk this up to only a manifestation of the disability, however; we also connected it to the fact that four-year-old children cannot self-regulate their behavior to fit what we adults think is appropriate. We have a responsibility to teach our children the right way to behave, not punish them and expect them to connect-the-dots on their own.

I propose a policy change in which pre-K students cannot be suspended or expelled. Pre-school children will not (dare I say, cannot) make the connection that being sent home was for “disrespect.” If we continue to punish our children by blocking them from an education because their age-appropriate attempts at independence are viewed as “refusals to obey school policy,” we are doing them and society a great injustice.

1http://www.msde.maryland.gov/NR/rdonlyres/A1A9320D-F78D-49CB-9565-9B8A68E924CD/26945/susp10.pdf, pp. 19-20

2http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/002015.htm

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School Pushout, Zero Tolerance | Comments Off on Suspended from Kindergarten…

Welcome to the Suspension Stories Website!

Poster by Caitlin Ostrow-Seidler

It has taken well over a year but we are pleased today to officially launch the Suspension Stories Website.  This initiative is a partnership between the Rogers Park Young Women’s Action Team (YWAT) and Project NIA.

This youth-led participatory action research project includes surveys, art, video, and audio.  In addition, you will find relevant resources including newspaper articles, reports, and other tools. We created this website based on what we thought would be useful to other students, parents, educators and organizers. As we embarked on our journey to better understand the parameters of the school to prison pipeline, we kept wishing that a site like this existed. We hope that you will find this useful to your work.

We are incredibly proud of this final product and hope that it will be of great use to the broader community as we all work together to end harsh school disciplinary policies and school pushout.  Ultimately, we hope that this site will serve as a platform for organizing to dismantle the school to prison pipeline.

We invite you to explore this site and ask that you complete this short five question survey to provide us with important feedback about our project.

Click here to take survey

P.S. You can find our Suspension Stories interviews at our Youtube Channel. We will continue to add more interviews to the channel as we collect them.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School Pushout, School to Prison Pipeline, Zero Tolerance | Comments Off on Welcome to the Suspension Stories Website!

This is really incomprehensible…

The Birmingham city school system, responding to a lawsuit challenging the use of pepper spray against students, argues that the system has no federal constitutional duty to protect students’ safety from the actions of third parties — in this case, police working as school resource officers.

At the federal appeals court level, school boards have frequently won lawsuits filed over student injuries on campus by using the argument about third parties, which also includes other students or someone else who is not a school employee.

An attorney defending the Birmingham school board in the lawsuit said Thursday that the argument does not mean the school system isn’t trying to protect students. “That does not mean that students are not protected by state law or school policies,” said Mark S. Boardman.

Birmingham schools’ mission statement says that the system is to “guide all students to achieve excellence in a safe, secure and nurturing environment.”

Other than their attorney’s comments, City school officials declined to comment Thursday on the filings, which ask the court to dismiss more than half of the 30 counts in the pepper spray lawsuit.

The Southern Poverty Law Center filed the federal lawsuit Dec. 1 against Birmingham city schools, Superintendent Craig Witherspoon, the assistant principal at one high school, Birmingham Police Chief A.C. Roper and several school resource officers in an attempt to stop the use of pepper spray to discipline children.

The Montgomery-based civil rights group filed the lawsuit on behalf of six students or former students of four Birmingham high schools — Woodlawn, Huffman, Carver and Jackson-Olin.

The lawsuit seeks a permanent injunction against the schools — and against police stationed there as school resource officers — from using pepper spray on students. It also seeks compensatory or punitive damages for the pain the students went through from the pepper spray that burned their eyes, skin and throats. The lawsuit alleges violations of the Fourth Amendment and the 14th Amendment because of the use of excessive force and failing to protect students.

Read the full article here.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies | Comments Off on This is really incomprehensible…

Suspensions Dramatically Increase in NYC & Disproportionately Target Blacks/Special Ed Students

The number of student suspensions in New York City public schools spiked dramatically over the past decade while the length of suspensions grew longer – a phenomenon disproportionally affecting black students and students with disabilities, according to a report released today by the New York Civil Liberties Union and the Student Safety Coalition that analyzes 10 years of previously undisclosed suspension data.

The report, Education Interrupted: The Growing Use of Suspensions in New York City’s Public Schools, analyzes 449,513 suspensions served by New York City students from 1999 to 2009.

The NYCLU and Student Safety Coalition obtained the raw data for the report through a series of Freedom of Information law requests to the New York City Department of Education (DOE) in 2008 and 2009. Statisticians and academics at the Annenberg Institute for School Reform at Brown University processed and analyzed the data for more than a year.

According to the data, the number of suspensions served each school year nearly doubled over the decade – even though the student population has decreased over the same period.

Among the report’s findings:

  • One out of every 14 students was suspended in 2008-2009; in 1999-2000 it was one in 25. Last school year, students served more than 73,000 suspensions. In the 1999-2000 school year, students served 44,000 suspensions, even though the overall student population was much larger than today.
  • Suspensions are becoming longer: More than 20 percent of suspensions lasted more than one week in 2008-2009, compared to 14 percent in 1999-2000. The average length of a long-term suspension is 5 weeks (25 school days).
  • Students with disabilities are four times more likely to be suspended than students without disabilities.
  • Black students, who compose 33 percent of the student body, served 53 percent of suspensions over the past 10 years. Black students with disabilities represent more than 50 percent of suspended students with disabilities.
  • Black students served longer suspensions on average and were more likely to be suspended for subjective misconduct, like profanity and insubordination.

The report partially attributes the rise in suspensions to the DOE’s Discipline Code – the code of conduct for the city schools that catalogues infractions and the acceptable range of disciplinary responses for each one. From 1999 to 2010, the number of behaviors for which a student must be suspended grew by 200 percent.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School Pushout, School to Prison Pipeline | Comments Off on Suspensions Dramatically Increase in NYC & Disproportionately Target Blacks/Special Ed Students

7 Year-Old Suspended For Finger Pointing…

Dispatch from Oklahoma:

OKLAHOMA CITY, Jan. 21 (UPI) — An Oklahoma woman said she was outraged when school officials gave her 7-year-old son an in-school suspension for pointing his finger like a gun.

School officials — without confirming the identity of the boy in question — said a student pointed his finger like a gun repeatedly, even after being told “on more than one occasion” not to do it.

Lydia Fox said her son, Patrick Riley, received an in-school suspension Jan. 14 from Parkview Elementary School in Oklahoma City for using his finger to simulate a gun. She said she pulled the first-grader from the school rather than have him submit to the punishment, The Oklahoman reported Thursday.

“He doesn’t really see why he got in trouble,” Fox said. “I don’t feel like he did anything to intentionally threaten or harass another student. It was just a 7-year-old boy being a 7-year-old boy.”

District spokeswoman Stacey Boyer said “a student attending Parkview Elementary has repeatedly used his hands to simulate a gun and act as if he is shooting fellow students. The child has been told on more than one occasion to stop this behavior. The parent was notified on multiple occasions and has met with the principal to further discuss the ongoing behavior.”

Boyer said she could not comment on disciplinary measures.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, Zero Tolerance | Comments Off on 7 Year-Old Suspended For Finger Pointing…

A Teen Suicide Leads to Questions about Harsh School Disciplinary Policies

From the Washington Post:

The apparent suicide of a 15-year-old high school football player in Fairfax County has sparked concern about the school district’s disciplinary policies, which critics say are overly punitive and often debilitating for students.

The concerns come as students at W.T. Woodson High School mourn the loss of Nick Stuban, a former sophomore running back on the junior varsity team. Football players wore their homecoming jerseys in memory of the well-liked teen Friday, and many other students wore black.

Nick’s death followed a disciplinary action that some parents and school activists considered unnecessarily harsh. A school spokesman defended the district’s policies as appropriate and in line with state law.

The teen was suspended and referred for expulsion last fall after an incident that his family and school officials declined to disclose. A hearing was held, and he was allowed to return to class in early January. At that point, he had been reassigned to Fairfax High School.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, Suicide | Comments Off on A Teen Suicide Leads to Questions about Harsh School Disciplinary Policies

Is America Criminalizing Childhood?

A dramatization of how U.S. schools are criminalizing students as young as 6 years old…

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School to Prison Pipeline | Comments Off on Is America Criminalizing Childhood?

Kev Martinez: ‘When I Do Math” Poem about School Pushout

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School Pushout | Comments Off on Kev Martinez: ‘When I Do Math” Poem about School Pushout

More Police, More Tickets, More Criminalization of Youth

With more police in schools, Texas kids get more tickets

Spike in tickets for kids as young as 6 as number of campus officers has increased

By TERRENCE STUTZ
Dallas Morning News

AUSTIN – Students in Dallas and other urban school districts in Texas are increasingly being charged with Class C misdemeanors for less-serious infractions that used to be handled with a trip to the principal’s office, according to a new study.

The report from the nonprofit advocacy group Texas Appleseed examined student disciplinary data on 22 of the largest school districts in the state. It found that most have sharply increased the number of campus police officers – resulting in far more misdemeanor tickets being handed out to students.

“Disrupting class, using profanity, misbehaving on a school bus, student fights and truancy once meant a trip to the principal’s office. Today, such misbehavior results in a Class C misdemeanor ticket and a trip to court for thousands of Texas students and their families each year,” the group said in the report, Texas’ School-to-Prison Pipeline.

“Criminalization of student misbehavior extends to even the youngest students,” the report said. “In Texas, students as young as 6 have been ticketed at school in the past five years, and it is not uncommon for elementary school students to be ticketed by school-based law enforcement.”

Black students have been disproportionately ticketed. During a recent school year in the Dallas school district, 62 percent of misdemeanor tickets were issued to black students, even though they make up 30 percent of enrollment.
Texas Appleseed offered several recommendations, including removing class disruption and misbehavior on school buses from the penal code.

The group also said ticketing students under 14 should be banned and ticketing older students should occur only as a last resort.

From the the Dallas Morning News.

Posted in Harsh Disciplinary Policies, School to Prison Pipeline, Zero Tolerance | Comments Off on More Police, More Tickets, More Criminalization of Youth

Zero Tolerance – A Comic

A terrific group of youth participated in a 5 session comic workshop series this past year. The series was sponsored by Project NIA, the Jane Addams Hull House Museum, and the Chicago Freedom School. The teaching artist was Rachel Williams. More information about that workshop series can be found here.

One of the pieces that was created as part of that comic workshop series depicts the consequences of zero tolerance policies. This piece was inspired by Suspension Stories’ Sent Down the Drain comic. We are thrilled that Sent Down the Drain provided some inspiration for creating this comic.

Created in the Just Us Comic Arts Workshop - November 2010

Posted in School to Prison Pipeline, Zero Tolerance | Comments Off on Zero Tolerance – A Comic